A Song of Fire: SP Campaign Feedback and Reviews

[Lord-Knightmare]

Updated to 1.0.5.81

Code: Select all

V 1.0.5.81
--> S19: fix typo in dialogue
--> Changed converted special characters (special thanks to oooo)
--> Fixed multiple bugs in unit files
    --> It's rather disappointing how these bugs carried over
        What has the previous maintainer been doing? Slacking?
        So many deprecated warnings here and not even patched...
--> Fixed Alenya's healing. Her sprite no longer disappears.
    --> Will animate it later. Remind me though
--> Liliel no longer demands upkeep
--> Celestial:
    --> Zealot-line: fixed attack icon missing bug

before the minotaurs of those darn blood-suckers get to her first!" -> before the minotaurs or those darn blood-suckers get to her first!"

I patched it. But will make it available in next release. Already made a release so no more today

It says at the beginning of the scenario that I won't be able to recall any dwarves. But I still can recall Thunder- and Dragonguards. (Which makes sense storywise (the dwarves are needed to cut down trees) but it doesn't mash with the message.)

I think having Dragonguards and Thunderguards against a massive horde of Drakes and 2-3 Fire Dragons seem fair. I wont change it.

[Lord-Knightmare]

Scythe Charioteer (Hannuk) and its advancement lack an image for the scythe attack.

Seems it didn't even have an icon to begin with. Oh, well..next release patch then.

[Konrad2]

S24 The Sun Path
S26 The Promise of the Rising Sun
Pls do not recreate Garmo. :C

It says at the beginning of the scenario that I won't be able to recall any dwarves. But I still can recall Thunder- and Dragonguards. (Which makes sense storywise (the dwarves are needed to cut down trees) but it doesn't mash with the message.)

I think having Dragonguards and Thunderguards against a massive horde of Drakes and 2-3 Fire Dragons seem fair. I wont change it.

There seems to be a misunderstanding. I do not wish for them to be not available (as it wouldn't make sense storywise), I want you to revise the story message about (all) dwarves being not available.

(Btw, next part of the Saga when? XD)

[Lord-Knightmare]

S20 Ring of Fire
S21 Will of the Naiad
S21 Will of the Naiad b
Pls do not recreate the Naiad every scenario, it's not pretty. :C

S24 The Sun Path
S26 The Promise of the Rising Sun
Pls do not recreate Garmo. :C

What do these even mean? They dont seem bugged.

(Btw, next part of the Saga when? XD)

I dont have time to playtest those long campaigns. If you can be or can offer playtesting slaves, then I can port and patch them. Otherwise, big NO.

[Konrad2]

S20 Ring of Fire
S21 Will of the Naiad
S21 Will of the Naiad b
Pls do not recreate the Naiad every scenario, it's not pretty. :C

S24 The Sun Path
S26 The Promise of the Rising Sun
Pls do not recreate Garmo. :C

What do these even mean? They dont seem bugged.

In those scenarios there is a unit Naiad/Garmo which reoccurs in a later scenario. But apparently not with the xp from previous scenarios, instead it's 'newly created' unit. I (personally) prefer if units like that are stored and reused instead of being recreated. Better continuity, and it looks better too.

Akashia has a 'normal' berserk attack, and I believe it should be attack only. (Her base unit has this berserk attack as attack only.)

[Lord-Knightmare]

But apparently not with the xp from previous scenarios, instead it's 'newly created' unit. I (personally) prefer if units like that are stored and reused instead of being recreated. Better continuity, and it looks better too.

"Too much effort, won't do it." - egallager, 2022

They don't get carried over either so no point.

[Konrad2]

S30
Old Friend
you do look rounder –

I have no idea why there would be something like this there.

Something about storing the dwarvish units in S26 went wrong. When I recall them in S31, they have less than 100% hp. (I guess they were stored before all units on the map were healed/restored.)

[egallager]

But apparently not with the xp from previous scenarios, instead it's 'newly created' unit. I (personally) prefer if units like that are stored and reused instead of being recreated. Better continuity, and it looks better too.

"Too much effort, won't do it." - egallager, 2022

They don't get carried over either so no point.

Hey now wait a moment! It's not like I'm the one who invented laziness! LOL

[Konrad2]

S34
have any on this planet, not anymore" -> have any on this planet, not anymore."



If you give me the next part of the series (without it crashing when it starts), I'll play(test) it.
EDIT: (Nice timing with A Song of the Winds, but that wrong direction for me. XD)

Spoiler:

ASoF-Fires of Hope replay 20221110-141508.gz

(140.21 KiB) Downloaded 35 times

ASoF-Ring of Fire replay 20221110-142832.gz

(123.07 KiB) Downloaded 36 times

ASoF-The Will of the Naiad replay 20221110-145409.gz

(99.9 KiB) Downloaded 39 times

ASoF-Where the Sun is Born replay 20221110-152236.gz

(123.98 KiB) Downloaded 35 times

ASoF-Holy Fire replay 20221110-153345.gz

(114.38 KiB) Downloaded 36 times

ASoF-The Sun Path replay 20221110-161311.gz

(139.06 KiB) Downloaded 33 times

ASoF-Wings of Rebellion replay 20221110-171536.gz

(183.47 KiB) Downloaded 38 times

ASoF-The Promise of the Rising Sun replay 20221111-171507.gz

(140.91 KiB) Downloaded 42 times

ASoF-The Rise of Maat'Kare replay 20221111-172726.gz

(122.52 KiB) Downloaded 37 times

ASoF-Embers of War replay 20221111-174451.gz

(134.91 KiB) Downloaded 33 times

ASoF-Forging Alliances replay 20221111-183022.gz

(156.4 KiB) Downloaded 40 times

ASoF-Old Friends replay 20221111-183425.gz

(100.66 KiB) Downloaded 39 times

ASoF-Night Fire replay 20221111-190942.gz

(136.97 KiB) Downloaded 39 times

ASoF-Fading of a Flame replay 20221111-193517.gz

(122.84 KiB) Downloaded 52 times

ASoF-The Valley of Silence replay 20221111-195947.gz

(132.37 KiB) Downloaded 37 times

ASoF-Wrath of the Heavens replay 20221111-204115.gz

(153.18 KiB) Downloaded 36 times

ASoF-A New Legend Rises replay 20221111-204246.gz

(81.32 KiB) Downloaded 39 times

[Lord-Knightmare]

If you give me the next part of the series (without it crashing when it starts), I'll play(test) it.

Since you have offered to be a playtesting slave, I suppose I can patch/undeprecate and port the last two.
As for the indirectly related SoW (Soldier of Wesnoth). That might take a while. due to Khalifate <=> Dunefolk conversion wrecking it by a considerable margin.

[reigenxd3]

Version 1.0.3
game version 1.14.16
ASoF-Lightning Strike - get the error of unknow tile in map (Cf) 'Cf'

[Lord-Knightmare]

...
Please Update to 1.16 as I am not supporting 1.14.x.

[MTF_alfa_158]

I give up. Every campaing is bugged,and i can't update to 1.16 soooo yeah,deleting everything.

[Ravana]

From your message I see you are using version earlier than 1.16. I understand it is unpleasant to need to stop playing after already starting addon, but it is extra work for author to try to support multiple versions at once.

For the bug report about 1.14 version it is just too late to improve anything. There are already plans for 1.18 so soon it might be too late for issues discovered in 1.16 as well.

[Lord-Knightmare]

Ported to 1.17.25. Not much noticeable changes.

Code: Select all

V 1.0.6
--> Ported to 1.17/1.18 servers
--> generated Pot file for translations